75k Email Marketing Contacts ❌

Posted by: Bri Guarnieri Date Posted: November 13, 2024
Back to Case Studies

Issue

Our client reached out and was looking for some advice around inbox monitoring software! They were seeing a lot of low engagement from their leads! After some back and forth, we established that they had roughly 75k email marketing contacts dating back to 8 or 9 years, and they were not explicitly asking for consent. Their disclosure was if you fill out this form, we can send you emails – no opt-in/out option. Their average open rate was 3% and their average click-through-rate was only 0.25%. They also received roughly 100 unsubscribes on every email they sent.

Here, I identified some big red flags based on the information they shared!

Solution

We hopped on a call to address these points, and I stressed the importance of…

  1. Cutting down this list! It is not in line with best practice to have unengaged contacts from 8 or 9 years ago.
  2. Explicit Consent is key! We have to allow our users to opt into communications on the website directly.

We had a pretty lengthy discussion here & I communicated the risks of not following these guidelines! Our POC seemed fairly bought-in at this point and understood the importance behind trimming this list down; however, he noted that Christine (who is not a POC we engage with) would have a hard time parting with older contacts.

Unfortunately, they proceeded without making the necessary updates or following our guidance!

The result: their Brevo account was suspended. Once this happened, the client informed the account manager and recognized that the changes needed to be made (which we’re in the process of doing). Essentially, exactly what we told them was at risk – happened!

Achievement

Not necessarily an achievement persay, but this was a learning experience for our client! They learned from their mistakes, and we built some trust in our expertise. A great resource for anyone looking to add some fuel when consulting with clients on email marketing!

I think this also stresses the importance of standing firm in our consulting and leaning into our team members – I wouldn’t have been able to speak to all the recommendations and risks without Emily’s support (shoutout our email team). It also shows the need to speak with people who ultimately have the most decision making power. Even though our main POC is the one sending out the emails, he ultimately didn’t have the final say in the audience segmentation and strategy.

Snippet/Screenshot/Link