Navigation and USP Clarity for Big Ticket Items

Posted by: Ath-raa Gamieldien Date Posted: July 24, 2025
Back to Case Studies

Issue

  • The use of confusing and unclear labels in the menu, causing a bottleneck for navigation to important category and product pages. The term “Classifieds” is very old-school and not typically what users would expect. It reads a somewhat salesy, and provides ineffective understanding of the value/solution being provided. The user was left questioning: How does this help me? What is this page about?

Solution

  • Relabel the menu item to provide clarity on what the category page is about, while providing a financial incentive to nudge users to engage
  • We tested different names for the “Classifieds” category tab in the menu to see if we can improve user engagement. Recap:
    • Original (Variant A): Classifieds
    • Variant B: Pre-Owned Metal Buildings
    • Variant C: Discounted Buildings

Achievement

Overall increase in conversion rate, conversions, and engagement metrics across all product pages due to the improvement of navigation to one category page. This A/B/C test saw over 16,000 views.
  • Overall, the Variant C Discounted Buildings saw overall higher conversions and conversion rates across all KPIs:
    • 29.95% increase in Classifieds Pageviews
    • 53.85% increase in Contact Us Pageviews
    • 55.49% increase in Classifieds Button Clicks
    • 30.26% increase in Search Feature Clicks (On the Classifieds page)
    • 33.07% increase in Featured Buildings Clicks (On the Classifieds page – if not using the Search Feature)

Based on these results, we can confidently say that the Discounted Buildings Variant is the winner.

Full breakdown of the KPIs measured

  • In the 2 weeks of testing we saw a 40.24% lift in key events and a 67.73% lift in session key event rate (compared to the preceding period)
    • Notably, with 431% lift in session key event rate on the /classifieds page alone

Snippet/Screenshot/Link