Lower Open Rates in EMFX: Why?

Posted by: Bri Guarnieri Date Posted: August 18, 2025
Back to Case Studies

Issue

The client had migrated from Constant Contact to EmailMarketingFX back in May, while onboarding with us. Since then, they’ve observed a steep drop-off in open rates, raising flags to their internal team.

Solution

Core Note: We do our best to filter out bot clicks & opens from our reporting, so EmailMarketingFX will typically have a lower open rate compared to other platforms; however, the lower open rate doesn’t mean that there is an issue with deliverability or the emails being sent.

  • Side Note: MailChimp is another email provider that does their best to filter out the spam/robo opens/clicks, so we may observe more similar open rates when comparing EMFX to MailChimp. 

Constant Contact Review – We proceeded with getting access to Constant Contact to dive in & evaluate potential flags and discrepancies –

The open rate versus click rate is extremely low, which is a solid indicator that these aren’t legitimate human interactions!

  1. Opens: If you export the opens for some of the campaigns and sort by date/time, you’ll see large ‘batches’ of opens. These ‘batches’ (same timestamp) are likely exactly when the email was delivered to that group of recipients (sheet used to identify batching here). Also, if you pull individual contacts, you’ll see the ‘fake’ opens based on their engagement (example screenshot – sent & opened at the same time)
  2. Clicks: If you open the list of clicks in a specific campaign, you’ll see several contacts that clicked every link in the email at the same time, which is also an indicator of fake/robo clicks (sheet used to view this here).
  3. We reviewed the clicks in Constant Contact from Jan-April against our clicks in EmailMarketingFX to ensure we’re looking at the same click metrics for comparison. Here’s what we found:
    1. Constant Contact Metrics: In January, CC reported 201 total clicks (not 201 clicks from unique people). In February, CC reported 213 total clicks. In March, CC reported 225 total clicks. In April, CC reported 152 total clicks.
    2. EmailMarketingFX Metrics: In June, we reported 134 total clicks. In July, we reported 210 total clicks. From our Customer Reactivation message, we reported 272 total clicks. From our Emergency Storm Support message, we reported 64 total clicks.
    3. Conclusion: When looking at clicks, our clicks have stayed fairly consistent (for the most part), especially considering we found instances of bot clicks within Constant Contact. Overall, it is fair to report that performance has remained steady from email marketing efforts across platforms. The decreased open rate is not a reflection of decreased visibility or performance, rather it is an indicator of differences in measurement across platforms.

Metrics to Review Instead: Instead of leveraging the open rate as the core metric for reviewing email performance, we should be leveraging metrics such as clicks, traffic to the site, phone calls from email marketing, and form submissions! These conversions and metrics are more reliable to use as indicators of performance.

Achievement

Educated the client on the importance of reporting on metrics other than open rate, due to the number of variables going into open rates & we addressed concerns around email deliverability in EmailMarketingFX.

Snippet/Screenshot/Link