Posted by: Cristina Pedroza Reyes
Date Posted: August 20, 2025
Back to Case Studies
Issue
- Sessions were up 4% MoM, but engagement and revenue-driving actions lagged—website clicks were flat, phone clicks down 10%, directions up 3%. New unique leads from local SEO declined 6% (CPL up 6% to USD 28.47). GA4 conversions fell 8% with a 4% conversion rate decline. Map views (-3%) and search views (-9%) suggested softer local visibility.
- Late-June GBP reporting glitches likely depressed local metrics, while seasonality (vacations/back-to-school prep) tempered July demand despite peak moving season.
- A gap between GBP visibility and on-site motivation (CTAs/trust elements) was likely suppressing conversions during a key period.
- In a post-report local campaign review, we found inconsistent UTM parameters and a few call tracking numbers that needed updating—creating attribution noise and undercutting confidence in phone vs. web lead performance. Not the only reason results were probably down, but it made the picture fuzzier.
Solution
- First, provide the full picture and plan:
- Framed the narrative: why metrics moved (seasonality + GBP glitch), where the funnel leaked (GBP-to-site handoff), and what we’ll change next—anchored to the client’s north star (qualified local moves at efficient CPL).
- Outlined actions to improve results: CTA audit, seasonal content (peak/back-to-school intent), GBP Offer Posts, keyword refinement for high-intent non-branded queries, and Local Maintenance.
- Completed (tracking and listings integrity):
- Corrected inconsistent UTM parameters on GBP listings to clean up GA4 attribution.
- Fixed several call tracking numbers to restore accurate phone lead tracking.
- Reviewed Bing Listings and resolved low confidence notifications.
- Expect cleaner call and website visit tracking starting in August.
- Next up (execution):
- Implement CTA audit and on-page CRO updates; publish seasonal/local-intent content; deploy GBP Offer Posts and refine keywords.
- September: run a competitor analysis to sharpen positioning and inform further CRO/CONTENT/GBP plays.
Achievement
- Clear, client-centered story in “reporting down” moments: connected data → context → decisions so stakeholders know what’s happening and what’s next
- UTM and call tracking corrections establish a trustworthy August baseline for calls and site visits.
- Prioritized actions to lift conversions and visibility without losing sight of the north star KPI set (qualified leads, conversions, CPL).
- The plan pivots with the data, not just “going through the motions.
Snippet/Screenshot/Link
