GA4 Key Events Not Populating After Freshpaint Migration

Posted by: Justine Jay Canete Date Posted: July 20, 2026
Back to Case Studies

Issue

After the GTM container was updated to Freshpaint (v12, published around May 11, 2026), all four core key events (nextpatient_appointment_click, contact_us, bottom_of_page_form, phone_click) stopped populating under Key Events in GA4. This affected reporting for the entire month of June 2026.
What made this tricky to diagnose at first glance was that everything appeared to be working on the surface. Tags were firing successfully in GTM Preview, and the events were showing consistent data in the GA4 Events report. For example, between May 1 and July 14, nextpatient_appointment_click had 2,248 event counts but only 294 key events, with nearly all of those key events concentrated before May 11. After that date, key events dropped to near zero while event counts continued at the same volume.
This is an unusual pattern in GA4. Normally if an event is marked as a key event in the GA4 admin, every instance of that event should be counted as a key event. Seeing a high event count with zero key events suggests that GA4 is receiving the events but something in how they arrive is preventing GA4 from applying the key event flag.

Solution

Added the conversion:true property to the Event Properties on each of the affected Freshpaint GA4 event tags in GTM:

  • GA4 – contact_us
  • GA4 – Event – nextpatient_appointment_click
  • GA4 – Event – bottom_of_page_form
  • GA4 – Event – phone_click

After publishing the updated container, confirmed in the network tab that the collect request now includes the _c parameter set to 1, which is GA4’s internal flag indicating the event is a key event (c = conversion = true). Also confirmed in GA4 Realtime that key events were populating correctly under Key Events by Event name.
Flagged the HIPAA allowlist requirement to the AM so they can coordinate with whoever manages the Freshpaint account to ensure the “conversion” property is allowlisted. Without this, Freshpaint may strip the property in HIPAA mode and the issue would return.

Achievement

Key events restored and confirmed firing correctly in GA4 Realtime and via the _c=1 parameter in the network collect calls. No actual data loss on the tracking side — all events were captured consistently throughout the affected period (May 11 through July 2026). The issue was limited to the key event designation, not event collection. Identified the root cause through a direct comparison of the GTM container JSON exports and confirmed the fix against Freshpaint’s official documentation.

Snippet/Screenshot/Link

Screenshot: https://webpagefx.mangoapps.com/msc/Mjk0MzI5NF8yNTI5MTY2NALink
Task: Link