Discrepancies Between Google and MCFX Data

Posted by: Melissa Shoff Date Posted: January 23, 2024
Back to Case Studies

Issue

While reporting on December 2023 number for PPC performance, the account manager noticed that Google Ads was not reporting on ~10 leads that she saw come into LMFX.

She noticed that we have 5 contact forms marked as “adwords” whereas others are marked as ppc mediums and wasn’t sure if that was a factor, but was looking for anything to explain this.

Solution

After digging into this we found a few things.

  • The Contact Us Form lead type was associated to many forms in the LMFX mapping (ss) and not just the contact us page form.
  • The Contact Us tag in Google Tag Manager which is pushing the conversion event to GA4 (and subsequently being imported into Ads) triggers when the referrer page contains /contact-us and the page path contains /thank-you-contact (ss)
  • I tested the Wander Management Contact Us form (ss) and upon submission I was taken to https://centrak.com/thank-you-request-a-demo. Then, I tested the Contact Us form and upon submission I was taken to https://centrak.com/thank-you-contact. Both are pulling in as Contact Us Form lead types, but I am routed to a different thank you pages. Only the contact us form would trigger your GA4 conversion event.

Because of this difference in how the tracking set up between LMFX and Google, the AM and client were see different numbers for the contact us form (an possibly other forms).

If we  relook at December’s results with this in mind, we see that of the 15 LMFX forms, only these five were actual contact us forms that would have fired the Google conversion event.

  1. Hany Fathy
  2. Gina-Lee Bezuidenhout
  3. Bernadette Hill
  4. Anjanette Gaane
  5. Tamekia Zahran

My recommendation and implemented strategy for moving forward was to revamp the actual form tracking within LeadManagerFX to align numbers with Google. This meant changing Lead Types to follow thank you page results that would fire Google conversions.

Achievement

  • Our numbers moving forward will now be more closely aligned with what they client might see in Google.
  • Contacts will be filtered into the appropriate Lead Type audience group for additional marketing purposes.
  • We build trust with our POC by being able to make recommendations and switches that are strategically focused on how they see and understand data.

Snippet/Screenshot/Link